I wrote this piece two years ago for a possible book entitled
“Misconceptions” that didn't create a deep enough burden in my soul to make it to a publisher...as if it would have been good enough anyways.
Sorry for the length, but
it won’t take you long to see where I stand if you want to skim the rest.
The reason I wrote about this topic is two-fold.
1. I grew up in a Christian environment that emphasized easy
prayerism and many of my friends who “prayed the prayer" are a far cry from exhibiting biblical discipleship.
2. I ask around 100 college students per year to share with me their testimony. Without exaggerating, 9 out 10 students that have
churched backgrounds tell me that they prayed a prayer earlier in life and
nothing changed spiritually. I began realizing that easy prayerism can be
disillusioning.
The greatest hindrance to biblical disciple
making is that we have minimized Christianity into a simple prayer.
Growing up as a kid, church camp was a weeklong
experience that every student in our church looked forward to. It was a refuge
from the typical teen’s life of sports, school, and relational drama. Friday
night at camp was always the emotional night when approximately half of the
youth group made some form of a decision. Perfectly rehearsed invitational
songs opened the floodgates of teens running to the alter after an emotionally
charged message.
After a “turn or burn” message, the preacher
asked everyone to bow their heads and close their eyes during the invitation in
order to make sure that noone was looking. Then he asked all the students to
slip up their hands if they wanted to “do business” with God. Some prayed the
sinner’s prayer and accepted Christ while others rededicated their life to
Christ. It wasn’t until later I realized that many students weren’t running to
God; they were running from hell and all they had to do was pray a prayer.
Secretly, I prayed the sinner’s prayer every
year of youth camp just in case last years prayer didn’t take. Needless to say,
repeating the prayer didn’t necessarily lead to a transformative life-changing
encounter with God. In fact, most of the students that made decisions stepped
right back into their previous lifestyle after leaving camp and going back
home. Now granted, all of us knew that the entire Christian experience didn’t
hinge on a simple prayer, but oftentimes, the evangelistic method we
encountered indicated otherwise. My defining moment came after realizing there
was not enough emotional inertia during the invitation time to produce a
life-long disciple of Jesus Christ and fear based evangelism lasted only as
long as the fear itself.
In our failed attempt to mass market the
gospel, have we really reduced the gospel into a simple prayer? We have all
heard this prayer at the end of a sermon when the preacher asks the
congregation to bow their heads and close their eyes.
“Heavenly Father, I am sorry for sinning
against you. I repent of my sins; please forgive my sins. I believe that Jesus
Christ died on the cross for my sins, and that He was raised from dead and now
lives at the right hand of the Father. I invite Jesus to be the Savior and Lord
of my life. Amen. “
The reality is that many people in evangelical
Christianity grow up in a church culture that centers around this magic and almost superstitious prayer.
Church History only records the use of the
sinner’s prayer within the past 500 or so years; such a prayer was a cultural
innovation that made evangelism tactics efficient and measurable. The Great Awakening
in the 1700’s recorded endless amounts of conversions resulting from
inspirational and emotionally charged preaching. Many preachers during The
Great Awakening forced the unregenerate on the front pew and preached
eschatological sermons specifically to them, publicly called out their names,
and prayed individually with them after the service. There is still much debate
today about whether preachers were manipulating people into conversion through emotionalist
trancing techniques. Of course, most of them
had good intentions and real conversions certainly took place under the
direction of the Holy Spirit. However, guilt driven messages greatly
manipulates, but rarely motivates. Emotions are the natural response to an
authentic regenerative experience; emotions should never be the fundamental
means to forcing a decision.
Unfortunately, I have heard well known
evangelists verbalize to me they had the ability to intentionally shed tears in
order to pull emotional strings in order to set the stage for the invitational
time. Ironically and sadly, these pastors are no longer in ministry because of
an “indiscretion”. This admission validated my assumption that guilt coercion
and deceptive communicative tactics were not spirit-driven at all, but rather,
nothing less than psychological manipulation. Nowhere in scripture do we ever
see intentional emotionalism in order to demand an invitational response. The
goal of Spirit driven evangelists should be “making disciples” not creating
converts.
The sinner’s prayer method surly led to
quantitative success in the evangelical world. However, many who have prayed
such a prayer leave confused and questioning the state of their relationship
with the divine because discipleship is overshadowed by evangelistic methods.
We are deceiving ourselves if we think God is dependent on our evangelistic
strategies.
Last year, our ministry at Arkansas State
University interviewed over eighty college students to help lead the vision of
our ministry. During each interview, we asked them to share their testimony and
focus on the moment they became a Christian. Amazingly, nine out of ten
students said they prayed a prayer as a young child, but nothing transformative
happened. 9 out of ten students said they weren’t really Christians after
praying that prayer! They would continue to tell a story of how someone led
them into a growing relationship with Christ, which validated their Christian
conversion. Some students told us about their Sunday school teacher, parents,
grand parents, youth pastor, or someone who told them how to live out their
faith.
Each student story made me wonder if we have adopted an evangelistic
strategy that confuses more than validates; one that is quantitative more than
qualitative, formulaic more than exhaustive, and man made more than biblical.
There is no verse that declares that conversion
happens in the context of prayer. However, this doesn’t mean it can’t happen in
the context of prayer; prayer is surly the result of trusting Christ as savior
and lord. It is vitally important that we talk to God in some manner as we
trust Christ as Savior and Lord. The sinner’s prayer is a practical method of
repentance and faith. Unfortunately, some people who pray this prayer not only
fail to continue into discipleship, but record no life change whatsoever.
In order to find the appropriate method of
evangelism, we should look no further than God’s Word. Scripture alone provides
a method that transcends cultural worldview and denominationalism. Culture
certainly does affect our evangelistic method, but it shouldn’t be the only
source of our methods. Ironically, today’s culture is strikingly similar to a biblical
culture. Millennials are unapologetically cynical to the evangelistic methods
of the past and desire trusting relationships with no strings attached and
agenda free. This became exceedingly clear to me after cultivating a
relationship with a self-proclaimed agnostic graduate student at Arkansas State
University. His criticism of Christianity weren’t the claims of Christianity,
but rather, the methods Christians use to promulgate the gospel. My take away
from this ongoing relationship was rather simple; as Christians, our love for
the irreligious must be unconditional for the sake of spreading the gospel to
the people who are looking for reasons not to embrace the gospel. Exhibiting
unconditional love for others will intentionally lead all of our conversations
with the people around us to Christ and the grace He offers. I can give you
countless testimonials how this looks in our ministry. The pursuit of
conversion should always be on a Christian’s mind, but, the method should be
tactfully chosen.
Evangelism is more caught than taught. It’s
relational not confrontational. Christianity is not a label we create for
ourselves, it is a lifestyle. Note that in the book of Acts, Christians didn’t
name themselves. The term Christian was coined by outsiders who observed the
lifestyles of Christ followers and concluded to name them “little Christs”
because they lived and acted just like Christ did.
So how should we test how people become
Christian? Testing evangelistic success should not be merely adding up the
number of people who are reached for first-time decisions; the real test of
evangelism is whether the people being reached are being baptized, discipled,
and reaching others. Most people accept Christ through friendships and
relationships. This shouldn’t be a big surprise because the people we know
oftentimes give us the most credibility. The Great Commission is an urgent command
to intentionally place ourselves in the lives of irreligious people for the
sake of leading them into a growing relationship with Jesus Christ. Put
differently, most people do not accept Christ from a stranger or other methods
that don’t emphasize authentic relationships and have a set agenda.
Christ has called all of us to “Go”. In Matthew
28, Jesus places the emphasis on disciple making and not mass conversions.
Making disciples connotes the lifelong pursuit of holiness through glorifying
Christ. Sharing the gospel is merely the first step in making disciples.
Disciple makers baptize as an external act of obedience to scripture. Any evangelistic methods that dodge follow-up methods are, at the least, a dangerous sugar
coated gospel that may be more damning than salvific. Consumeristic
Christianity or easy believism may indeed be the reason for a decline in twenty
first century baptisms and certainly an enemy to the church. Such a gospel
allows people to live as though God doesn’t exist; this is no gospel at all. There
is very little difference in the way people who claim to be Christians behave
when compared to the irreligious. American Christianity has packaged grace in a
way to get all the goods of salvation for none of the sacrifice it ought to
create. Real grace not only absolves the sin, but also, liberates the sinner
from sin itself. Liberation from sin takes place in the context of repentance.
Following Christ will Cost you; however, the
cost of not following Christ is much greater. Consequently, there is no
Christianity without discipleship. A profound life transformation into the
likeness of Christ is is the natural result of an authentic conversion. True
faith is the facilitator of human to holy. While we become Christian at one
point in time, authentic initial faith inevitably becomes continual. Should the
appropriate response to God’s grace be anything less.
Discipleship isn’t necessarily found in TV
evangelism, tracks, and the latest program or curriculum; look no further than
Jesus’ relationship with his disciples to find a biblical method.
The kingdom of God will not be advanced through
man made growth strategies including excellent programming and quick and easy prayerism
that’s more like a drive through than your local McDonalds. Jesus’ strategy was
fundamentally simple, “make disciples” Making disciples is the only effective
way His kingdom will be advanced. In order to make disciples, we have to
overcome our spectacular emphasis on the number of converts and provide more
emphatic attention towards making disciples who make disciples.
Becoming a fully devoted follower of Christ is
not an option; Praying a prayer, going to church, and affirming certain beliefs
is simply not enough. We should live in such a way that it is obvious to
everyone we are Christ followers. Discipleship is essential for every
Christian, not just an option for super Christians. The measure of churches
shouldn’t be how many people pray a prayer, but rather, how many people are
disciple making. Healthy churches mature and grow godly believers lead others
to believe. Put differently, grace is evidenced in the spirit of the redeemed,
transformed, obedient, and identifiable saints. Change is the prerequisite to
discipleship; we are called to be changed, embrace change, and initiate change
in others.
Faith is not merely emotional, educational,
environmental, or experiential; faith is transformational and alive. The most
productive life in God’s kingdom can only be experienced by dying to the flesh
and the world.
The time is now to call for a practical
marriage for evangelism and discipleship.
Questions:
What is the inward
and outward witness of your lifestyle?
What lifestyle
evidence does your life of conversion, commitment, and consecration?